Homemade Marshmallows


Marshmallows are one of those things that are very nostalgic for people.  Every time I see a recipe that turns someone into a child again it always seems to have marshmallows in it! I am a huge sucker myself, but I cannot seem to find a brand out there that makes marshmallows without crazy processed sweeteners and stabilizers like corn syrup.  After a bunch of research and, of course, trial and error… I have figured out a perfect marshmallow recipe that you won’t feel bad about eating.


This recipe is very much a gourmet version of the well known marshmallow because it has two of my favorite ingredients, honey and vanilla beans.  I like to buy the honey raw because it is in it’s purest form.  I know vanilla beans are pricey, but they make these sooooo good and it’s worth trying at least once.  This recipe can be made with vanilla extract instead, but I would add it in when the marshmallows are being whipped instead of when the honey is boiling like when you add the beans in.  These marshmallows have a wonderful floral taste from the honey AND a warm and rich taste from the vanilla. They are SO easy that you will never want a store bought marshmallow again!

Vanilla Bean

3 Tablespoons unflavored gelatin
1/2 cup room temperature water
2 cups honey (I prefer raw/organic)
1 vanilla bean split and seeds (2 teaspoons if you are using extract instead)
1/4 teaspoon salt (I used Kosher)
*Sprinkle the gelatin over the water in the same bowl you will be doing your mixing in.  Let sit for 5 minutes so that the gelatin is absorbed by the water.  Meanwhile, oil and 13×9 inch baking pan.
*In a sauce pan whisk together the honey and salt over medium heat.  Add the vanilla bean and the seeds! Turn the heat to medium/high and bring the mixture to 240 degrees using a candy thermometer whisking every so often if needed.
Vanilla Bean Seeds
*Once the mixture has reached 240 degrees removed the vanilla bean pod with tongs and very slowly add the honey to the gelatin mixture on low/medium speed.  Once it is all added turn the mixture to high and beat for about 10 minutes.  The mixture should be light and fluffy.  It’s really fun to watch this happen!
*Pour into prepared baking pan and let set at room temperature, overnight, uncovered.  This is the hard part…. you cannot cut them until the next day.
*When you are ready to cut the marshmallows you are going to want to remove them from the pan.  Just loosen up the sides of the pan and it should slide out.  To make them easier to cut I sprinkle them with powdered sugar.  You can use a knife, but a pizza cutter will work as well.  Then toss the small pieces in a bowl with some powdered sugar and evenly coat.  If you are using these to make Rice Krispies then you don’t necessarily need this step.
I found that they are best the day after you make them.  This recipe makes a lot so I actually freeze what I don’t use and pull them out when I need to make a quick dessert like rice krispie treats.

5 Responses to Homemade Marshmallows

  1. Hi, Love you on H&F. You remind me of when I was younger. I still love to cook and have had my share of catering and making wedding cakes. Cant wait to try this fluff recipe. Keep up the good work, I am also going to make the snowball arrangement you made for winter, I make a lot of arrangements for my friends and my church. I am going to send you a Halloween idea I used for school parties and my neighborhood.

Leave a reply

Copyright © From Scratch With Maria | Design by The Nectar Collective
Privacy Policy